feministcrixus:
zemmer:
In this context, I am using the word “queer” as an umbrella term for gay, bisexual, pansexual, trans*, and gender-variant people. I recognize that it is not ideal, and I am sorry for that.
For those of you who don’t understand the concept of queer-baiting,…
DrSilverfish adds: In this interesting discussion I would caution against, however, making TPTB into a monolithic entity out to “bait” queer audiences. The truth is that there is the Network, the Channel, the Advertisers/ Sponsors, the Producers, the Writers, the Actors and last but definitely not least, the Editors, involved in the production of narrative television drama.
Some of those folks might be LGBTQ or LGBTQ-allies and write or interpret or edit queer moments or suggestions into scenes along the way, even where that wasn’t the overall “master-plan”. Historically, this is how many instances of queer representation made their way into filmic subtext. If any of you who might be interested haven’t seen the excellent documentary ”The Celluloid Closet” based on Vito Russo’s equally excellent book, then I thoroughly recommend it.
In particular Gore Vidal, as script-writer on the Hollywood blockbuster Ben Hur (1959) talks about how he attempted to infuse a gay subtext (that the hero Judah Ben-Hur and his friend Massala had previously been lovers) into the text, with, according to Vidal, the active collaboration of Stephen Boyd who played Messala but unbeknownst to Charlton Heston, who played Ben Hur.
Often the only way queer subtext (not textual allusion there to be laughed at) appeared in filmic representation historically was thanks to queer Hollywood.
So, we do not know the behind-the-scenes politics regarding Supernatural and Dean’s sexuality. It is, in my view, too simplistic to refer to an entity “the show” as “queer-baiting”. I will, for instance, eat my hat (although I know this is just speculation) if Edlund is not squeeing as hard as any Destiel fan at the beautiful hero-as-bisexual “coming out” story he potentially has on his hands, other parts of the machinery being willing.
So yeah, I’m not one (yes, I identify as queer, in case that needs saying) who would rather have no queer subtext regarding Dean in SPN unless all-out definitive canon is on its way. Representation sometimes happens incrementally, and each step paves the way for the next one.